stories from the wilder side of science


Crucifixion Experiments

Posted on April 14, 2011 at 4:33 PM

No other Christan holiday is linked to more bizarre experiments than Good Friday. The crucifixion of Jesus Christ initiated a long and fierce debate among physicians and clergymen. They were arguing  serious questions like: was Jesus nailed or tied to the cross? Did the nails penetrate the hands or the wrists? Which angle formed the outstretched arms of Jesus? And most importantly: how did Jesus die? As the bible provided little information on these subjects there was only one way to find out, doing experiments!

Crucifixion researchers relied on a steady stream of fresh cadavers and amputated arms and legs. That's probably why most of them had been doctors in hospitals unscrupulous in using for their studies whatever remained on the operation table after surgery. Around 1900 for example Marie Louis Adolphe Donnadieu, professor at the catholic faculty of sciences in Lyon, France, nailed a cadaver of a man on a wooden board (picture at the right) for the sole reason that a seemingly petty question could be answered:  Would the hands  have supported Jesus without the nails tearing through the flesh.

The horrific picture in his book Le Saint Suaire de Turin devant la Science - a body hanging from one arm stitched to the board - was to him the final prove that his opponents have to abstain once and for all from the theory that Jesus was not crucified by putting nails through his hands. The only worry Donnadieu had was, that " the light for the picture didn't offer the best aesthetic conditions."

But if Donnadieu thought the gross demonstration had proven his point beyond any doubt he was mistaken. Some thirty years later another catholic surgeon, Dr. Pierre Barbet, complained about the low quality of Donnadieus cadaver. In his book A Doctor at Calvary Barbet writes about Donnadieus experiment: "The picture shows a pathetic small very skinny emaciated body ... the cadaver I crucified in contrast ...  was totally fresh and smooth" (picture in the middle). The French surgeon also did experiments with "living arms" (meaning: just amputated) he attached weights to in order to prove that the nails were hammered through the wrists and not through the hands. But much more important than this revelation was the insight that the arms formed an angle of 130 degrees which allowed at last for an anatomical correct depiction of Jesus at the cross: the so called Villandre-Cross sculpted by the surgeon Charles Villandre with the help of the information gained by the experiment with Barbets cadaver.

Barbet also determined asphyxiation as the cause of death of Jesus only to be contradicted by the latest and foremost authority in the field of crucifixion, the American pathologist and Medical Examiner Frederick Zugibe.

As crucifying cadavers has come out of fashion lately Zugibe was working with volunteers whom he bound to a DIY cross in his garage measuring critical bodily functions like pulse, blood pressure and respiration (picture at the right). He is convinced that Jesus didn't die from asphyxiation but from traumatic and hypovolemic shock. Finding volunteers by the way was surprisingly easy. Members of a free church nearby were lining up to feel once like Jesus.

Reto U. Schneider is the deputy editor of NZZ Folio and the author of The Mad Science Book.

Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In


Reply Christopherarroyo
1:31 AM on November 4, 2017 
You are shared a very useful post, I am very impressed on your simple writing style. I am an online service provider; if you need any type of writing help you can visit my website. This article is use simple, straightforward sentences with few modifying phrases and clauses.I enjoy articles that have one big word that fits perfectly. It makes me feel the article was worthwhile , no matter what.
Reply ebay calvin klein bikini
12:15 AM on July 1, 2018 
efence as the Danes waltz through down the right without a care in the world and force Schmeichel to intervene and block Santander’s cross-cum-shot…sunsportonline18th October 20167:52 pmLEI v COP: And now skipper Wes Morgan is really hobbling…sunsportonline18th October 20167:53 pmLEV v TOT: Hugo Lloris gets away with a suicidal short pass out to Danny Rose there when it all it needed was a proper punt forward.
ebay calvin klein bikini
Reply C Programming Project Help
3:30 AM on July 12, 2018 
The Leading Assignment Help UK Firm Offers State Of The Art Services To Its Clients With A Promise Of Delivering All The Required Work Well Within The Deadline. C Programming Project Help
Reply C Programming Project Help
3:31 AM on July 12, 2018 
This Is Really Great Work. Thank You For Sharing Such A Good And Useful Information Here In The Blog For Students.
Reply Do MY Computer Science Assignments
7:11 AM on July 12, 2018 
I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great Work Thanks For The Share.
Reply Mik sims
2:48 PM on March 19, 2019 
How do I get involved being crucified in a experiment
Reply Kelgrorce
2:01 PM on August 24, 2019 
Kamagra Barato Kamagra Criticas Flagyl 500 Acquistare Levitra On Line Di Cialis Rezeptfrei Bestellen
Reply Audrey Fitchett
10:14 AM on September 9, 2019 
I have never have any interest in chemistry in my whole life but I don?t hate the experiment because they are so fun to do that. We can get amazing ideas from this site to how to make money nz and this site is very helpful for all people to earn more. Theory is kind of really bore but we learn more from the experiments more because something that is happing live, it?s easy to remember that.
Reply Field Engineer
7:49 AM on February 19, 2020 
Very nice blog, Thanks for sharing grate article.
You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
Keep posting like this informative articles.
Thank you.

From: Field Engineer
Reply Oliver123
7:49 AM on February 20, 2020 
I appreciate your writing style.
Our traffic analysis reporting and capacity planning will allow you to forecast the growing needs of your managed WiFi services- Read More: